Mahkamah Kekalkan Award Tribunal RM20,110 untuk Kecacatan Rumah
· Rumah Bumi Johor
If your new house has defects that the developer keeps failing to fix, a March 2026 High Court decision is encouraging. The Melaka High Court dismissed a developer bid to overturn a Homebuyer Claims Tribunal award of RM20,110.50 to a couple over defects, and ordered the developer to pay RM8,000 in costs. The court said the tribunal was entitled to rely on a technical inspection report and to award money instead of giving the developer more time, because the defects were still not repaired.
Updated 17 Nov 2026. General information, not legal or financial advice.
The case
Free Malaysia Today reported the judgment on 19 Mar 2026. Judicial Commissioner K Raja Segaran dismissed the judicial review filed by developer Jun Cheng Development Sdn Bhd against buyers Nur Amira Samsudin and Arief Rosali, over a house in Taman Kota Sungai Rambai, Melaka.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 30 Mar 2023 | Couple signs the sale and purchase agreement |
| After handover | Couple sends formal defect notices, gives repeated chances and extensions; repairs not done |
| 28 May 2025 | Tribunal orders the developer to pay RM20,110.50 |
| Mar 2026 | High Court dismisses the developer judicial review; RM8,000 costs |
Why the developer lost
- The tribunal could lawfully get and rely on a technical inspection report under the Housing Development (Control and Licensing) Act 1966.
- Both sides were invited to the site visit and both received the report before the award.
- The developer did not bring its own technical report or expert evidence, so it had no basis to challenge the findings.
- Because the defects were continuing, the tribunal could reasonably award compensation instead of more time to repair.
Just got your keys in Johor?
Ask us for a simple defect checklist before your defect period runs out.
What Johor buyers can learn
- Report defects in writing, with photos and dates, within the defect liability period in your SPA. Under the standard agreements this is usually 24 months from vacant possession. See Schedule G and Schedule H.
- Give the developer a fair chance and a clear deadline to repair, and keep copies of every notice and reply. The couple in this case did this, and it helped.
- If repairs are not done, you can file a claim at the Homebuyer Claims Tribunal under KPKT. The Federal Court has said each distinct claim can be up to RM50,000, as long as the claims are about different issues (EdgeProp, 2023).
- Attend any site inspection the tribunal arranges and bring your records.
- Before you buy, check the developer track record on TEDUH.
This was a Melaka case and every claim turns on its own facts. But the principle that a tribunal can rely on an independent inspection, and can award money when a developer keeps failing to repair, is useful for buyers anywhere in Malaysia, including Johor.
Defects and your Bumi lot purchase
A Bumi SPA price 15% lower than the non-Bumi price lowers your price, but it does not lower your rights. A Bumi lot buyer has the same protection on defects and late delivery as any other buyer under the sale and purchase agreement. Do not accept poor workmanship because you paid less.
Common questions
Can the tribunal order money instead of repairs?
In this case the court said yes, because the defects were continuing after repeated chances to fix them.
Do I need my own engineer report?
Not always. The tribunal in this case relied on a technical inspection report, shared with both sides. Your own photos and notices still matter.
How much can I claim at the tribunal?
Each claim is capped at RM50,000. The Federal Court has said distinct claims about different issues can each be within that limit.
Want a developer with a good handover record?
Tell us your area. We will share options and what past buyers say.
More guides: Property law, family and strata
Sources:Free Malaysia Today, 19 Mar 2026; EdgeProp, 22 May 2023. General information, not legal or financial advice. Cover photo: Lallaoke, Unsplash.
[…] Tiada rayuan ke mahkamah sivil; satu-satunya laluan ialah semakan kehakiman atas alasan ketidakteraturan. Jika pemaju tidak bayar, hantar kepada Tribunal tiga salinan Notis Ingkar Award dan lima salinan award. Tribunal akan majukan kepada Mahkamah Majistret. Gagal mematuhi award ialah kesalahan yang boleh membawa denda, penjara sehingga dua tahun, atau kedua-duanya. Untuk contoh sebenar, baca mahkamah kekalkan award kecacatan RM20,110. […]